The Art of Constructive Criticism: Thoughts from Creatives

Advertisements
2–3 minutes

Hey everyone! As an artist, I’ve been thinking a lot about feedback lately, especially when it comes to constructive criticism. It’s such a crucial part of our growth, right? I’d love to hear your thoughts on this too—how do you feel about giving or receiving feedback?

For me, I totally welcome constructive criticism. It’s a great chance to learn and improve, both as a person and as an artist. Don’t get me wrong; it’s always nice to hear positive things, but I find that feedback—especially the constructive kind—can really push me to the next level. Still, I get that it can be tricky to navigate, especially when it comes from someone you don’t really know.

When constructive criticism is delivered well, it can be super effective. It’s all about being thoughtful and considerate, but I also see how it can be tough for artists, particularly those just starting out. There’s always that worry about how feedback will be received. Even the best-intentioned comments might not land as you hoped.

So here’s my little dilemma: while I’m all for feedback, I often hesitate to give it to someone I don’t know well. I get that you don’t necessarily have to know someone to offer constructive criticism; it’s just my comfort level. Plus, if it’s done right, I really believe it will be taken in stride, or at least I hope!

I want to throw out a couple of questions for all you creatives out there:

  1. Are you okay with giving constructive criticism to someone you don’t really know?
  2. How do you approach that balance of offering helpful feedback without crossing any lines?

For me, I’ve learned that it’s best to build some kind of rapport before I dive into critiques. Getting to know the person a bit helps me understand how they might take feedback, and it sets a chill tone for the conversation.

In the end, constructive criticism is kind of an art in itself. It takes a bit of sensitivity and understanding. At the heart of it all, we want to help each other grow while keeping things supportive and open.

Let’s keep this convo going! How do you handle constructive criticism—whether you’re giving it or receiving it? I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences!

Advertisements
Advertisements

Discover more from The Flawed Artist

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Responses

  1. Darryl B Avatar

    I wouldn’t offer CC unless I was asked. If I was, I’d use the old standby: positive, positive, CC, positive.

    “What do you think of my painting?”

    “Wow, I really love the way you captured that old barn. And the way the trees shade the pasture fence is so realistic. Maybe just a few more details could add depth: a milk can, or a few garden tools. But it’s a beautiful piece…you have a gift.” 😎

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Keito + Kanvas Avatar

      I totally agree! The “sandwich” method is a great way to give feedback. Your example nails it; it shows off the good parts while offering some friendly suggestions. It’s a nice way to encourage artists and help them improve. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. CattleCapers Avatar

    Some in the younger generations seem to be particularly sensitive. It’s great that you want to consider the feelings of others, but giving constructive criticism will help a future career. May I suggest pointing out what is positive then framing the criticism like, “May I suggest this change?”

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Keito + Kanvas Avatar

      That’s a good point! It’s important to balance being sensitive with helping others grow. Framing feedback positively, like suggesting changes, can definitely make a difference. Thanks for the advice!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. traciesulpazo Avatar

    I think it’s like giving a review. I like to give a positive comment first and then maybe a little constructive feedback then end again with a positive. Yes, it may be a formula, but it is a formula that has worked forever in the business world. It should work for creative too.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Keito + Kanvas Avatar

      Absolutely! That formula really works well, whether it’s in business or in creative fields. Starting and ending with positivity makes the constructive feedback easier to take. It’s all about encouraging growth while still celebrating what’s great. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. veerites Avatar

    Dear Keito
    I was quite impressed by your post. It has given a new point of view.
    Thanks for liking my post, ‘Walk’ 🙏

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a reply to traciesulpazo Cancel reply

Discover more from The Flawed Artist

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading